Common Core State Standard
SL.CCS.1/2/3/4 Grades 6-12: An essay of a current news event is provided for discussion to encourage participation, but also inspire the use of evidence to support logical claims using the main ideas of the article. Students must analyze background information provided about a current event within the news, draw out the main ideas and key details, and review different opinions on the issue. Then, students should present their own claims using facts and analysis for support.
FOR THE WEEK OF MAR. 01, 2010
Damage spreads when writers use the Net to plagiarize
Most news and feature section content comes from original reporting, writing and other creativity. Show an example you think took a lot of work.
Some traditional newspaper offerings present basic facts that are the same in all papers, which isn't plagiarism. Find or name something in that category.
List or discuss reasons why newspapers generally are trustworthy information sources.
The ease with which content can be remixed these days not only has eliminated every technological barrier to plagiarism, but also enabled some jaw-dropping justifications for this utterly indefensible practice.
Wait -- we have to confess something very important now. We didn't really write that first sentence. We copied it from a Feb. 16 journalism blog post by Alan D. Mutter of California to show what it means to plagiarize -- which is pronounced PLAY-jar-EYES and means using someone's sentences or original phrases without credit.
The misdeed, which has been in the news lately, ranks right up there with inventing facts or quotes as one of a nonfiction writer's worst sins. It erodes readers' trust, betrays a fellow writer and undercuts the editorial safeguards aimed at reinforcing credibility of published material. That's why two recent examples brought career-harming penalties.
New York Times business reporter-blogger Zachery Kouwe resigned last month after being suspended for copying parts of Wall Street Journal and Reuters articles without credit. A week earlier, the Daily Beast news website dismissed chief investigative reporter Gerald Posner for lifting the work of other journalists.
Former editor Alan Mutter, the blogger quoted with belated credit earlier here, explains why this matters: "The practice is intellectually dishonest. . . . It is wrong to steal someone's bicycle and it is wrong to steal someone's ideas or work product in order to represent it as your own."
Newspaper says: "The Times has dealt with this . . . consistent with our standards to protect the integrity of our journalism." -- Diane McNulty, spokeswoman, commenting on writer's departure Feb. 16, 2010
TV commentator says: "It's amazing -- especially these younger people, who are very coherent about what's going on in the Internet era -- think they could get away with something like this. . . . It can be checked instantly." -- Cal Thomas, "Fox News Watch" program, Feb. 20, 2010
Blogger says: "The reason bloggers don't often plagiarize is that we don't need to. We can make a point by piggy-backing off of factual statements or opinions from others, and easily make it clear that we didn't say it first. " -- Michael Roston at trueslant.com
Front Page Talking Points
is written by
Felix Grabowski and Alan Stamm for NIEonline.com, Copyright 2017
We welcome comments or suggestions for future topics: Click here to Comment
Front Page Talking Points Archive
Presidential swearing-in: Ceremonies, parade and dancing on a historic Friday in Washington, D.C.
Fake news, Part 2: How to be a smart reader who isn’t tricked by viral nonsense
Fake news, Part 1: Made-up stories shared widely online can have a real impact, 2016 events show
Energy and environment: Tribe wins North Dakota oil pipeline fight -- for now
Donald Trump’s media criticisms and provocative tweets push journalists to explore different coverage
Fidel Castro, longtime leader of Cuba’s Communist revolution, dies at age 90 in Havana
Bargain-hunters will bolt from Thanksgiving tables to catch holiday gift sales
These issues and plans are atop Donald Trump’s agenda as our next president prepares to lead
Election drama beyond the presidential race: Which party will have a U.S. Senate majority next term?
World Series has extra drama as the Cubs and Indians each struggle to end many decades without a championship