For
Grades 9-12
, week of
Aug. 10, 2026
1. SENATE VOTES TO HOLD DR. FAUCI IN CONTEMPT OF CONGRESS
The Senate Homeland Security Committee voted along party lines to hold Dr. Anthony Fauci in contempt of Congress after he repeatedly invoked the Fifth Amendment during testimony about the COVID-19 pandemic. Republicans argue that because President Biden issued Dr. Fauci a preemptive pardon covering actions during much of his government service, he no longer had the right to refuse to answer questions. Dr. Fauci’s legal team disputes that interpretation, maintaining that invoking the Fifth Amendment was appropriate because he could still face legal risks, including possible perjury charges. Legal experts are divided over whether a presidential pardon removes Fifth Amendment protections in these circumstances. Democrats criticized the contempt vote as politically motivated and argued that Congress should instead support an independent bipartisan investigation into the origins of the pandemic and the government’s response. The dispute highlights broader constitutional questions about congressional oversight, executive pardons, and the protections afforded to witnesses under the Fifth Amendment. Create a legal argument map with two sides: one defending Dr. Fauci’s use of the Fifth Amendment and one supporting the Senate committee’s contempt resolution. For each side, identify at least three arguments from the story and note any legal precedent or constitutional principle that strengthens the position. Finish with a brief assessment of which argument appears more legally persuasive based only on the information provided.
2. AMAZON’S A.I. DATA CENTER RAISES CLIMATE QUESTIONS
Amazon confirmed that it is investing in a massive natural-gas power plant to supply electricity for a new artificial intelligence data center in Texas. If the facility operates at its permitted capacity, it could become the largest single source of carbon dioxide emissions in the United States. Amazon argues that generating power on-site will avoid increasing electricity costs for other Texans and help meet the enormous energy demands of rapidly expanding A.I. technology. The company also says it remains committed to its long-term climate goals and is exploring renewable energy and battery storage at the site. Environmental organizations, however, warn that the project could worsen air pollution, increase greenhouse gas emissions, and undermine Amazon’s public commitments to reducing its environmental impact. The controversy reflects a growing challenge facing technology companies as the rapid growth of artificial intelligence increases electricity demand faster than clean energy infrastructure can expand. Write a short essay that evaluates whether governments should offer incentives or restrictions for energy-intensive A.I. data centers. Analyze the economic benefits, environmental costs, and energy reliability concerns discussed in the story. Conclude by proposing two policy requirements that could balance technological growth with environmental protection.
3. TODD BLANCHE CONFIRMED AS ATTORNEY GENERAL
The Senate narrowly confirmed Todd Blanche as U.S. attorney general after an unusually contentious confirmation process. Blanche previously served as acting attorney general and was formerly President Trump’s personal defense attorney, leading critics to question whether he would maintain the Justice Department’s independence from the White House. Several Republican senators expressed concern about Blanche’s role in negotiating a controversial legal settlement that included protections for President Trump and proposals for a multibillion-dollar federal compensation fund, although some senators ultimately supported him after receiving written assurances that key provisions would not move forward. Others remained unconvinced, arguing that the Justice Department must remain independent regardless of which political party controls the presidency. The confirmation illustrates the ongoing debate over the balance between presidential influence and the traditional independence of federal law enforcement agencies. Write an essay evaluating why the independence of a justice department is considered important in democratic governments. Using examples from the story, explain how confirmation hearings can serve as a check on executive power, identify the concerns raised by both supporters and opponents of the nomination, and assess how Senate oversight may influence future executive branch decisions.
4. MORE READERS ARE CHOOSING TO “DNF” BOOKS
The abbreviation “DNF,” meaning “Did Not Finish,” has become increasingly common among readers, especially after Goodreads introduced a feature allowing users to officially mark books they choose not to complete. Supporters of DNF argue that readers have limited time and should not feel obligated to finish books they are not enjoying. Others believe completing a book leads to a more informed opinion and respects the author’s work. Authors themselves are divided, with some accepting that not every book connects with every reader, while others acknowledge that unfinished books can be disappointing. The discussion has grown through online reading communities and social media, where readers increasingly share their reading habits and opinions. The debate raises larger questions about personal choice, cultural expectations, and how digital platforms influence reading behavior. Design a small research study exploring why people decide to finish or abandon books. Identify a research question, create five survey questions, explain how you would collect responses, and describe how you would analyze the results to determine whether factors such as age, available free time, genre preferences, or social media recommendations influence reading habits.
5. UNIVERSITY INVESTIGATES PROFESSOR’S RECORD
Jason Arday resigned from the University of Cambridge after the university announced an investigation into questions surrounding his academic qualifications and parts of his professional record. Arday, who became Cambridge’s youngest Black professor in 2023, had attracted international attention for his personal story of overcoming significant developmental challenges before earning a doctorate and becoming a leading scholar. Recent reports, however, have raised allegations involving plagiarism, résumé discrepancies, and claims about aspects of his biography. Arday denies wrongdoing, argues that many of the accusations are unfair or motivated by racism, and says the intense public scrutiny has taken a heavy personal toll. Cambridge has stated that it is conducting a formal investigation before reaching any conclusions. The controversy highlights the importance of academic integrity, careful fact-checking, institutional accountability, and fair investigative procedures when questions arise about scholarly work. Assume you are serving on a university committee responsible for protecting research integrity. Draft a policy outlining how universities should investigate allegations of academic misconduct while also protecting the rights of the accused. Your proposal should address evidence collection, due process, transparency, the role of independent review, and how institutions should communicate with the public before investigations are complete.